Understanding Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) in Risk Management

Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) is a systematic and structured technique used to identify and evaluate potential failures in a system, process, or product. It is a widely used risk assessment method that helps organizations prevent failures, reduce costs, and improve product quality. Let’s explore the components, steps, and applications of Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA).

FMEA Steps

The FMEA process typically follows these steps:

• System Definition: The system or product to be analyzed is clearly defined, including its boundaries and key components.
• Failure Mode Identification: Potential failure modes for each component or step in the process are identified. A failure mode is a specific way in which a component or process can fail to perform its intended function.
• Failure Effects Analysis: The potential effects of each identified failure mode are analyzed. A failure effect is the consequence of a failure mode, which can range from minor inconveniences to catastrophic events.
• Risk Priority Number (RPN) Calculation: The severity, occurrence, and detection of each failure mode are assigned a numerical rating. The RPN is calculated by multiplying these three ratings, providing a relative measure of the overall risk associated with each failure mode.
• Control Measures Identification: Control measures are identified to mitigate the risks identified in the FMEA. Control measures are actions or procedures that can be implemented to prevent or reduce the likelihood or severity of failures.
• Control Measures Effectiveness Assessment: The effectiveness of the identified control measures is evaluated, and the residual risk is recalculated. Residual risk is the risk remaining after implementing control measures.
• Action Plan Development: An action plan is developed to implement the identified control measures and to monitor the effectiveness of risk mitigation efforts.

FMEA Benefits

Failure Mode and Effects Analysis offers several benefits, including:

• Proactive Risk Identification: FMEA helps organizations identify potential failures before they occur, allowing for proactive prevention and mitigation.
• Improved Product Quality: By preventing failures, FMEA can help organizations improve product quality and reduce defect rates.
• Reduced Costs: FMEA can help organizations reduce costs associated with product recalls, warranty claims, and downtime.
• Enhanced Safety: FMEA can help organizations identify and mitigate potential safety hazards, improving workplace safety and reducing the risk of accidents.
• Improved Decision-Making: FMEA provides a structured framework for evaluating risks and making informed decisions about product design, process improvement, and resource allocation.

FMEA Applications

FMEA is widely used in various industries, including:

• Aerospace: To prevent failures in aircraft, satellites, and other aerospace systems.
• Medical Devices: To minimize risks associated with medical implants, surgical equipment, and pharmaceutical products.
• Automotive: To enhance the safety and reliability of automobiles and automotive components.
• Manufacturing: To improve the quality and efficiency of manufacturing processes, reduce downtime, and prevent product defects.
• Software Development: To identify and address potential software defects and ensure the reliability and security of software applications.

The FMEA is a valuable tool for organizations that want to proactively identify and mitigate risks, improve product quality, and enhance safety and reliability.

FMEA Formula and Calculation:

Risk Priority Number (RPN) Calculation:

RPN is computed by multiplying three factors: Severity (S), Occurrence (O), and Detection (D) ratings assigned to each failure mode.

FMEA formula:

RPN = S × O × D

Calculation examples for Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)

Here are some calculation examples for Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA):**

Example 1: Severity Rating

Consider a component of a medical device that is responsible for delivering medication at a precise rate. A potential failure mode could be a malfunction that leads to overdosing or underdosing of the medication.

The severity of this failure mode could be rated as high, with potential consequences such as patient injury, hospitalization, or even death.

Example 2: Occurrence Rating

The occurrence rating for this failure mode could be moderate, with a likelihood of occurring once in every 1,000 devices.

Example 3: Detection Rating

The detection rating for this failure mode could be medium, with a probability of detecting the failure before it reaches the patient of 70%.

Example 4: Risk Priority Number (RPN) Calculation

Using the severity, occurrence, and detection ratings, the RPN can be calculated as follows:

RPN = Severity x Occurrence x Detection RPN = High x Moderate x Medium RPN = 4

Example 5: Control Measures Identification

Based on the high RPN, control measures can be identified to mitigate the risk associated with this failure mode. These measures could include:

• Implementing stricter manufacturing and quality control procedures
• Installing warning systems to detect malfunctions
• Providing regular maintenance and calibration of the component
• Example 6: Control Measures Effectiveness Assessment

The effectiveness of the identified control measures can be evaluated to determine the reduction in risk. For example, if the control measures can reduce the likelihood of the failure mode to once in every 10,000 devices and increase the detection probability to 90%, the RPN would be recalculated as follows:

New RPN = (Severity x Reduced Occurrence) x Reduced Detection New RPN = (High x 1/10,000) x 0.9 New RPN = 0.09

Example 7: Action Plan Development

An action plan can be developed to implement the identified control measures and to monitor the effectiveness of risk mitigation efforts. This plan should include specific responsibilities, timelines, and resource allocation.

Example 8

Let’s say we have identified a failure mode with:

• Severity (S) rating = 7
• Occurrence (O) rating = 5
• Detection (D) rating = 8

RPN = 7 (S) × 5 (O) × 8 (D) = 280

By following these steps, organizations can effectively utilize FMEA to identify, evaluate, and mitigate risks, leading to improved product quality, enhanced safety, and reduced costs.

Photo credit: Tumisu via Pixabay

Risk Assessment Techniques | Identifying, Assessing, and Mitigating Risks with Proven Techniques